This problem set tests your mastery of integral calculus across Chapter 2. Problems span foundational Darboux sum analysis, partition proofs of integrability, the Leibniz-Newton Fundamental Theorem with dynamic boundaries, and geometric area decomposition.
Problem 2.P.1: Integrability of Step Functions
Let be a step function; that is, there exists a partition of such that on each open subinterval for some constant At the partition points may take arbitrary values in
Prove from the partition integrability criterion (Definition 2.1.2
HintExpandCollapse
Refine by placing narrow subintervals of width around each boundary point where differs from the constants Since there are only boundary points and is bounded, the total variation contributed by the boundary spikes can be bounded by
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
Let Since takes only finitely many values,
Given choose such that Construct a refined partition by placing symmetric intervals around each interior partition point (and at endpoints).
On subintervals where is constant the supremum equals the infimum, so The only subintervals contributing to are the intervals enclosing the partition points There are at most such intervals, each of width at most on which
Therefore:
By Definition 2.1.2
Problem 2.P.2: Upper and Lower Darboux Integrals of a Linearly Modulated Dirichlet Function
Define by:
Compute the exact upper Darboux integral and lower Darboux integral and deduce whether is Riemann integrable on
HintExpandCollapse
On each subinterval use the density of and to show that and Compare with the upper and lower sums of
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
Let be any partition of On each subinterval with
- By density of rationals in come arbitrarily close to the right endpoint where Since for all we have
- By density of irrationals in come arbitrarily close to where Hence
Therefore, for every partition where is continuous and integrable on with Taking the infimum of and supremum of over all partitions Because is not Riemann integrable on
Problem 2.P.3: The Oscillation Criterion for Integrability
For a bounded function and any subinterval define the oscillation of on by
Prove that is Riemann integrable on if and only if for every there exists a partition such that:
HintExpandCollapse
Rewrite the definition of by grouping terms with the common factor
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
By definition of the upper and lower Darboux sums: Notice that
Therefore, the sum is identically equal to
The claim follows immediately from the Darboux integrability criterion (Definition 2.1.2
Problem 2.P.4: Integrability of Thomae's Ruler Function
Thomae’s function is defined by:
Prove that is Riemann integrable on and that despite being discontinuous at every rational number in
HintExpandCollapse
Notice that for any there are only finitely many fractions in with denominator Everywhere else,
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
First, for every partition every subinterval contains irrationals where Since so for all Thus,
To prove integrability, we must show that Let Choose an integer such that The set of points consists solely of rationals with denominator The cardinality is finite.
Choose such that Construct a partition of having maximum subinterval width Partition the index set into two disjoint sets:
- indices where
- indices where
Each point in can belong to at most 2 adjacent subintervals, so On these intervals, Thus:
On good intervals, everywhere, so Thus:
Combining both sums:
Since is Riemann integrable by Definition 2.1.2
Problem 2.P.5: Stationary Points of a Variable-Limit Gaussian Integral
Define the function by:
- Use the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus (Theorem 2.2.1) and the Chain Rule (Theorem 1.2.4Theorem 2.2.1Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, Part 1Let be a Riemann integrable function, and let be continuous on . Define the accumulation function by:) to computeTheorem 1.2.4The Chain RuleIf is differentiable at , and is differentiable at , then the composite function is differentiable at , and:
- Find all critical points where and determine the exact maximum value of on
HintExpandCollapse
Split the integral at as differentiate using the Chain Rule, and observe when or when the upper and lower limits coincide.
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Derivative via FTC Part 1 and Chain Rule:
Let Since is continuous everywhere, Theorem 2.2.1
2. Critical Points on On both and so On and Notice that at we have and so and: For for Thus is the unique critical point and global maximum on with value
Problem 2.P.6: Accumulation of the Floor Step Function
Let be the floor function and define the accumulation function for
- Derive an explicit piecewise formula for on
- Prove that is continuous on the entire interval but fails to be differentiable at the interior jump points and Explain why this behavior is consistent with Theorem 2.2.1.Theorem 2.2.1Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, Part 1Let be a Riemann integrable function, and let be continuous on . Define the accumulation function by:
HintExpandCollapse
On on on Accumulate the area subinterval by subinterval and compare one-sided derivatives at and
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Explicit Piecewise Formula:
- For
- For
- For
2. Continuity and Non-Differentiability at Jump Points:
At and at Thus is continuous on
However, at the left-hand derivative is while the right-hand derivative is At while Thus and do not exist.
This is consistent with Theorem 2.2.1
Problem 2.P.7: Critical Analysis of an Accumulation Function
Let be defined by
- Find all critical points of on and classify each as a local minimum, local maximum, or inflection point.
- Determine the intervals on which is concave upward and concave downward.
- Identify the location of the absolute minimum of on
HintExpandCollapse
By FTC Part 1, Find where and check the sign of
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Critical Points:
The integrand is continuous on By Theorem 2.2.1
2. Concavity and Inflection Points: Differentiating using the quotient rule: Setting yields Since and the numerator is strictly positive for all (at it is at at Therefore, for all meaning is concave upward on the entire interval
3. Absolute Minimum: Since decreases on and increases on the absolute minimum on occurs uniquely at
Problem 2.P.8: Locating the Mean Value Point for Integrals
Consider on the interval
- Calculate the exact average value
- Find all values of that satisfy the Mean Value Theorem for Integrals (Theorem 2.1.4), such thatTheorem 2.1.4Mean Value Theorem for IntegralsIf is continuous, then there exists some such that:
HintExpandCollapse
Evaluate the integral using FTC Part 2 (Theorem 2.2.2
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Definite Integral and Average Value:
An antiderivative of is
By Theorem 2.2.2
2. Mean Value Point:
By Theorem 2.1.4
Problem 2.P.9: Area Between Cubic and Linear Curves
Compute the total area of the finite regions bounded between the cubic curve and the line
HintExpandCollapse
Find all intersection points by solving Note that the curves intersect at three points, so the area must be split into two separate subintervals where the top and bottom curves alternate.
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Intersection Points: Set The intersection abscissae are and
2. Relative Positions:
- On test Cubic: Line: Since
- On test Cubic: Line: Since
3. Integration: Notice that the integrand is an odd function, so the areas of the two lobes are symmetric: The total enclosed area is
Problem 2.P.10: Horizontal Versus Vertical Slicing
Find the area enclosed between the two parabolas and Set up and evaluate the integral with respect to and explain why horizontal slicing is computationally preferable to vertical slicing for this region.
HintExpandCollapse
Solve for the -coordinates of intersection by equating the two formulas for Then integrate
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Intersection Points: Set The curves intersect at and
2. Orientation: For test (left curve). (right curve). Thus and
3. Horizontal Slicing: Integrating:
4. Comparison with Vertical Slicing: Solving for yields and solving yields Integrating with respect to requires splitting the domain into three separate piecewise subintervals and and integrating radical expressions on each. Horizontal slicing requires only a single, simple polynomial integral.
Problem 2.P.11: Parabolic Tangent Area Invariance
Let For any positive constant consider:
- The parabola
- The tangent line to the parabola at the point
- The vertical -axis
Prove that the area of the region bounded by these three curves is always equal to which is precisely one-third of the area under over
HintExpandCollapse
Find the equation of the tangent line at using Then integrate the vertical difference from to
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Tangent Line Equation: The derivative of is so the slope at is The tangent line equation in point-slope form is:
2. Bounded Region: On the interval the parabola lies above its tangent line: The region is bounded on the left by on the right by from above by and from below by
3. Area Integration: Applying vertical slicing: Using the substitution with (or expanding directly):
Since the tangent region area equals exactly one-third of the enclosing bounding rectangle and matches the area under the parabola.
Problem 2.P.12: Darboux Sum Convergence for the Cubic Monomial
Consider on the interval For each let be the uniform partition with equal subintervals of width with division points for
- Using the cubic power-sum identity derive closed-form formulas in terms of for and
- Prove that as
- Deduce directly from Definition 2.1.2.Definition 2.1.2Riemann IntegrabilityLet be the set of all possible partitions of . We define the **lower integral** and **upper integral** of on by:
Code Exercise
Compute Upper and Lower Darboux Sums for f(x) = x^3
def darboux_x3(n): # For strictly increasing f(x) = x^3 on [0, 1] with uniform partition of width 1/n: # Upper sum uses right endpoints x_i = i / n u_sum = sum(() * (1 / n) for i in range(1, n + 1)) # Lower sum uses left endpoints x_{i-1} = (i - 1) / n l_sum = sum(((i - 1) / n) ** 3 * (1 / n) for i in range(1, n + 1)) return (l_sum, u_sum, u_sum - l_sum)
HintExpandCollapse
Apply with for the upper sum and for the lower sum.
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
1. Closed-Form Darboux Sums: Since is strictly increasing on on each subinterval we have and with Using
2. Darboux Gap Convergence:
By Definition 2.1.2
3. Value of the Integral: Taking Therefore
References & Further Reading
- Spivak, M. (2008). Calculus (4th ed.). Publish or Perish.
- Abbott, S. (2015). Understanding Analysis (2nd ed.). Springer.
- Bartle, R. G., & Sherbert, D. R. (2011). Introduction to Real Analysis (4th ed.). Wiley.
- Apostol, T. M. (1967). Calculus, Vol. 1: One-Variable Calculus, with an Introduction to Linear Algebra (2nd ed.). Wiley.