Where the previous lessons established the existence and evaluation of the definite integral, this lesson turns to geometric and physical modeling. The central modeling decision is to choose a thin slice or element, express its measure in terms of the integration variable, and sum the elements in a limit.
Area Between Curves
If and are continuous on and there, the region between their graphs has area
The order is not optional: if the graphs cross, split the interval at every intersection or integrate When horizontal slices are simpler, solve for as a function of and use
The shaded region is the geometric object represented by the integrand:
For and the intersections are and the line is above the parabola on that interval. Hence
Pause & Predict: Crossing Curves & The Vanishing Net Area Trap. Consider computing the geometric area between and on What happens if you directly evaluate without finding intersection points? Commit your reasoning before opening the analysis below.
Show hintExpandCollapse
Recall that geometric area is strictly positive. If the curves cross, what does naive signed integration do to the opposing regions?
Reveal analysisExpandCollapse
Analysis: Directly integrating gives: The naive algebraic integral yields zero because the positive region between and is exactly cancelled by the opposite regions on and Geometric area is strictly positive: one must split at the intersection points to integrate
Curve Crossing Check
Consider and on . Evaluate each statement regarding the enclosed geometric area and integration:
Classify each option as correct or incorrect, or leave uncertain options unanswered (“I don't know”) and verify at any time.
Volumes by Slicing
Let a solid have cross-sectional area perpendicular to the -axis. If is integrable, Cavalieri’s slicing principle gives
Revolving a region about the -axis produces disks of area when there is no hole, and washers of area when the inner radius is Shells instead use cylindrical strips: revolving a vertical strip of radius and height about the -axis gives
For the region under on rotation about the -axis gives
Arc Length and Surface Area
Approximate a smooth graph by line segments. For the distance element satisfies
Therefore:
If is continuously differentiable on its graph has length
If is continuously differentiable on its graph has length
Rotating the graph about the -axis sweeps out a band with circumference so for a nonnegative
These integrals frequently have no elementary antiderivative; numerical quadrature is then part of the mathematical solution, not a failure of the model.
Worked Trace: Exact Arc Length Evaluation for
Consider finding the exact arc length of the curve on the interval
-
Differentiate the Curve:
-
Formulate the Arc Length Differential:
-
Set Up the Definite Integral:
-
Integrate via Substitution: Let so When when
Counterexample & Failure Mode: Gabriel’s Horn (Finite Volume, Infinite Surface Area)
When integration applications are extended to unbounded domains, geometric intuition can break down dramatically. Consider revolving on the interval about the -axis.
-
Volume via Disk Slicing: The volume is finite! It could be filled with exactly cubic units of paint.
-
Surface Area via Revolving Bands: Because for all
-
The Painter’s Paradox Breakdown: The surface area diverges to infinity while the volume remains strictly finite This paradox demonstrates that three-dimensional measure (volume converges much faster than two-dimensional boundary measure (surface area warning against conflating surface and volume scalings on unbounded regimes.
Mass, Work, and Average Value
For a one-dimensional object with linear density a slice of width has mass giving
If a variable force moves an object from to in the positive direction, the work is
The same accumulation logic yields the average value of a continuous function:
Worked example. A two-metre rod has density kg/m, where is measured in metres from one end. Its mass is kg. Its average density is kg/m. Dividing by length is appropriate for average density, not for the total mass.
Deep Practice
Set up and evaluate definite integrals for area between curves, volumes by disks/washers and shells, arc length, and physical accumulation.
Exercise 2.3.1: Area Between Two Intersecting Parabolas
Find the exact area of the bounded region enclosed by the curves and
HintExpandCollapse
Solve to locate the intersection points, verify which curve lies above on that interval, and integrate the difference.
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
- Intersections: Set
- Upper vs. lower curve: On at we have so is the upper curve.
- Evaluate the area integral (using even symmetry):
Verification criteria. Requires finding setting up and evaluating to
Exercise 2.3.2: Volume of Revolution by Cylindrical Shells and Washers
Consider the planar region bounded by and on
(a) Set up and evaluate the volume when revolved about the -axis using washers (Theorem 2.3.1
Model selection
A planar region is revolved around the -axis with vertical strips of height at distance . Evaluate each statement:
Classify each option as correct or incorrect, or leave uncertain options unanswered (“I don't know”) and verify at any time.
Fill-in Exercise
Set up the washer cross-sectional area
Thus the washer cross-sectional area is , where the outer term and .
HintExpandCollapse
For (a), outer radius and inner radius . For (b), shell radius is and shell height is .
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
- (a) About the -axis (washers):
- (b) About the -axis (cylindrical shells):
Verification criteria. Requires exact integrals and values and
Exercise 2.3.3: Exact Arc Length of a Semicubical Parabola
Using Definition 2.3.2
HintExpandCollapse
Differentiate to get , so . Integrate on .
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
- Derivative and arc-length integrand:
- Integrate via Definition 2.3.2:Definition 2.3.2Arc Length of a GraphIf is continuously differentiable on , its graph has length
Verification criteria. Requires computing and evaluating the integral to
Exercise 2.3.4: Work Required to Pump Liquid from a Cylindrical Tank
A vertical cylindrical tank of radius and height is filled to the brim with water of weight density Set up and evaluate the definite integral for the total work required to pump all the water over the top rim of the tank.
HintExpandCollapse
Slice the water horizontally at depth below the rim. Each disk slice has volume , weight , and is lifted a distance .
Worked solutionExpandCollapse
- Slice geometry at depth below the top rim:
- Cross-sectional area:
- Slice volume:
- Slice weight (force):
- Lifting distance to the rim:
- Accumulate work:
- Substitute
Verification criteria. Requires defining the depth coordinate expressing slice weight and lift distance and evaluating the integral to
References & Further Reading
- Spivak, M. (2008). Calculus (4th ed.), Chapter 18 (“The Logarithm and Exponential Functions”) & Chapter 19; for higher-dimensional volumes, Fubini’s theorem, and surface integrals over manifolds, see Spivak (1965), Calculus on Manifolds, Chapters 3–5. Publish or Perish.
- Apostol, T. M. (1967). Calculus, Volume 1: One-Variable Calculus, with an Introduction to Linear Algebra (2nd ed.), Chapter 2 (“Some Applications of Integration”) and Chapter 14 (arc length and rectifiable curves). Wiley.
- Stewart, J. (2015). Calculus: Early Transcendentals (8th ed.), Chapter 6 (“Applications of Integration”) and Chapter 8 (“Further Applications of Integration”, hydrostatic pressure and centroids). Cengage.